Canadian green party member argues for both sides of ethanol argument
I was checking out the blog of an old friend that I grew up with, who now lives on Prince Edward Island. PEI is an island province on the Atlantic coast of Canada, and apparently they are trying to cash in on the ethanol boom. An ethanol production plant is being proposed for construction in Georgetown, PEI. The leader of provincial Green party there, Sharon Labchuk, is ambivalent about having a local production plant. Her party's most recent national election platform is very supportive of biofuels and resolutions that came out of their most recent party convention go even farther. They propose having 20 percent biofuel content in Canada by 2020, not collecting sales taxes on the biofuel fraction of fuel sales and diverting federal GMO biotechnology research funds towards organic food production and efficient biofuel crop development. This sounds like they support ethanol and other biofuels. However, this week Ms Labchuk characterized ethanol production as a "huge hoax" and raised concerns about air and water pollution from the plant.
Based what's being said, it sounds more like the PEI Green party is suffering a case of NIMBY. They want to support biofuel production and use as long as that production takes place somewhere else. Admittedly, ethanol, particularly from corn is controversial, but for the moment it is the most viable biofuel in North America and the Green Party might want step back and decide what they really want.
[Source: ruk]
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Sharon Labchuk 1:53PM (10/05/2006)
Your comments were brought to my attention. No, the Green Party of PEI is not suffering from NIMBY. This is more a case of the PEI media looking to stir up controversy. My opposition to this proposed ethanol plant (and all ethanol plants) was expressed as leader of the Green Party of PEI. Support for ethanol comes from the 2006 election platform of the FEDERAL Green Party of Canada. The federal party has no official relationship with any of the provincial parties at all. Even though this was explained to CBC in my interview, they chose to spin it the way they did.
I will be working to ensure the federal party does not include support for ethanol in its next election platform, and did oppose its inclusion in the last one.
Sharon Labchuk
Reply