Editorial: Gears: The more the merrier?
Is it solely a case of one-upmanship that is driving the number of forward gear ratios forward in today's passenger cars? Or, are consumers choosing vehicles based on the number of gears in the transmission? I am not entirely sure, but I do know that I would consider passing on a vehicle just because it only has a four-speed transmission. As rare as they are today, some vehicles, like the GM full-size pickups, are still using four-speed automatic transmissions. Before you comment, I know that they are being phased out in favor of the new six-speeders. But, a little research shows that Mercedes and BMW offer seven speed automatics, and Lexus has an eight speed for their top-of-the-line model. Why so many gears? Efficiency is one reason, and performance is the other. We'll start with the latter.Do you remember the old Power-Glide trannys that GM used when muscle cars were just hitting the scene? I'm not old enough to remember, but I have experienced them after-the-fact. They worked fine, but if you were cruising in second gear and hit the gas causing a downshift, it might be rather abrupt, because there was only one choice for the transmission to make. In the newer trannys with more gears, there are many choices. For instance, imagine cruising in gear eight, you hit the gas ... depending on how hard and at what speed you are traveling, you could drop to seventh for a gradual acceleration, or to fourth for fast pick-up. Conversely, only having two forward gears in the Power-Glide allows for excellent reliability and it also makes them predictable, which is why they are still popular transmissions for drag racing.
Now, as far as efficiency is concerned, if you are driving slowly, the transmission can up-shift to a lower numeric gear ratio, saving gas in the process. I have never driven a car with more than six forward gears ... so I can't say what the driving experience is like, but it is certainly a market trend to increase the number of forward gears. For maximum efficiency, a manufacturer may choose a CVT with an infinite number of ratios, but some consumers don't like the driving experience with them. So I would expect to see more and more new transmissions like this ZF with eight forward gears. The more the merrier?
[Source: Gizmag]
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Mulad 11:02AM (5/04/2007)
Well, they've probably reached the point of diminishing returns by now. According to the article, it returns 14% better efficiency than "an automatic 5-speed transmission which is still widely used today", whatever that means, exactly. And it's 6% better than a 6-speed transmission the company already produces. Heh, at this rate, their next step would be a 12-speed which does 3% better...
I suspect they're really competing with dual-clutch or sequential automatics like DSG. Of course, the logical response would just be to create an 8-speed DSG...
Well, hopefully my next car will have an electric drivetrain and I won't have to worry about silly things like gear ratios.
Reply
Tony Belding 7:27AM (5/05/2007)
I thought the industry stuck with 4-speed automatics for too long. Now it seems they are rushing to over-compensate. . . and pushing up against diminishing returns, as the article suggests.
And yes, it will all become moot when cars move to an electric power train, where one or two gears is plenty.
Reply
MikeW 2:27PM (5/04/2007)
That 6% is over the new generation of 6 speed autos. (6hp21,28,34)
Larger ratio spread, but how much? 7:1
BMW doesn't have a 7 speed automatic, they have a 7 speed automated manual.
The model T had a 2 speed planetary transmission 2.74:1 ratio spread (that or 1:1 gear, Low/High)
The Neon 3 speed auto (1993-2001 model year) had 2.69:1 (1st-2.69,2nd-1.55,3rd-1)
Reply
greatslack 2:24PM (5/04/2007)
@ Mulad, I agree, I think we need to get out of the 1900s with these mechanical designs and start working on better electric motors.
Reply
MikeW 10:51AM (5/05/2007)
Well ZF did introduce their 5 speed auto in 1990. (JATCO claims 1989 for their 5 speed auto)
http://www.jatco.co.jp/ENGLISH/PRODUCTS/at_history.html
and GM introduced their 4 speed auto in 1939, and wasn't GM's 1st 5 speed auto the 5L40, and wasn't that in the E39 5 series at launch (at least for Europe, the US didn't get that transmission until the 2000.5 528i (M52tu engine)
Reply
MikeW 10:59AM (5/07/2007)
Wow 7.01:1 ratio spread.
http://dieselblog.net/2007/05/zf-will-build-an-8-speed-automatic-great-news-for-diesels/
Reply