Ethanol promoters attack Big Oil, OPEC in Nashville
Oh, the poor ethanol industry figures. Maligned for their reliance on corn, blamed for rising food prices and having to resort to subsidized fuel sales to attract attention, ethanol is an easy target these days.. Ethanol can't even get any love from the chickens. Last week, ethanol promoters gathered in Nashville to lash out at OPEC and Big Oil, and to figure out how ethanol will fare in the coming years. Around 4,000 people attended the 2008 Fuel Ethanol Workshop and Expo, according to organizers BBI. There is a lengthy video of the opening session now available online here.In the video, the president and CEO of the Renewable Fuels Association,Bob Dinneen, breaks into a bit of a tirade about the oil industry. Dinneen's message is that the oil companies are waging war against renewables through paid-for studies and newspaper editorials. The ethanol industry's solution? Mandate that all new vehicles in the U.S. be E85-capable (we assume they mean all current gasoline-powered vehicles). Author Robert Zubrin said this would drive gas prices down to $50 a barrel. I say if cellulosic ethanol companies can make good on their promises to sell ethanol for something like $2 a gallon, you won't need a mandate to get all cars to be E85-ready.
Press Release:
Ethanol Industry Fights Back in Nashville
NASHVILLE, Tenn., June 23 /PRNewswire/ -- The Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries is taxing the industrial world into a global depression and Big Oil is behind this year's vicious assaults on corn-based ethanol. The world's largest ethanol conference began with those blunt messages last week here in Music City, USA, where nearly 4,000 people gathered for the 24th annual International Fuel Ethanol Workshop & Expo (FEW), a BBI International event.
The dramatic opening session, featuring a provocative speech by Robert Zubrin, author of Energy Victory: Winning the War on Terror by Breaking Free of Oil, is now available online at http://www.ustream.tv/channel/2008few
28 minutes into the video, Bob Dinneen, president and CEO of the Renewable Fuels Association, tells the audience that the oil industry has staged a massive propaganda campaign against ethanol. According to Dinneen, the oil industry saw one-third of its market share slipping away and concocted an enormous campaign against renewables. "They sit on editorial boards of every major newspaper," he says, adding that Big Oil "bought themselves some studies" and teamed up with major food companies to create a giant smokescreen. "They need to stop us now, but they won't," he says, adding that rising food prices are in part due to demand from developing countries like China and India and changing diets of people around the world. Of course, the price of oil is paramount to this debate, and Dinneen hit home this message by saying, "We can't produce $2.50 corn with $4.50 diesel."
Approximately 1 hour and 20 minutes into the video Zubrin gives a compelling account of the OPEC's strategic will to control global oil output and prices. In 1972, the United States spent $4 billion on oil imports, or 4.5 percent of the U.S. defense budget. This year, the United States will spend $650 billion on imported oil. As Zubrin puts it, "$650 billion isn't just money, it's power."
Zubrin -- who sold more than 500 books after his speech -- tells the audience that OPEC has placed a "slow choke" on world oil supplies, and the only way to "change the trump suit" is by mandating all vehicles sold in the United States to be flex-fueled (E85 capable) giving consumers a fuel choice. A flexible-fuel vehicle mandate would end the chicken and egg dilemma that's hampered the development of E85 refueling infrastructure. "This would crash the oil price to $50 a barrel," he tells the crowd. "This is how you smash OPEC."
Watch the entire opening session of the FEW, free of charge, at http://www.ustream.tv/channel/2008few
About the FEW:
The International Fuel Ethanol Workshop & Expo (FEW) is the premier international conference for ethanol plant personnel, equipment manufacturers, service providers and developers. The show's technical workshops offer featured panels on emerging technologies like corn fractionation, cellulosic ethanol, water and energy efficiency, non-fossil fuel power, plant management and safety. This year, the FEW Expo featured more than 600 exhibiting companies and an international networking pavilion. The 25th annual FEW -- the event's silver anniversary -- will be held in Denver June 15-18, 2009. For more information, visit http://www.fuelethanolworkshop.com/.
[Source: BBI International]
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Whopper 4:21PM (6/24/2008)
"Mandate that all new vehicles in the U.S. be E85-capable" Yeah, what industry wouldn't like to have the government mandate that their product must be used. The nice thing about free markets is, assuming the market is permitted to act freely, the market place will find the best solution and reward the providers.
Reply
Mark Mitchell 5:15PM (6/24/2008)
Zubrin is among the biggest cheerleaders for this particular mandate and I've heard and read quite a bit of comment by him on the subject but I'm not convinced. If E85 can't compete with $4 a gallon gasoline without hefty tax breaks its long term viability is in serious question, mandate or not. Current E85 availability has seemed not to have put any brake on crude prices and even worse its price has risen in tandem with gasoline. What part of that equation can possibly equal crude tumbling to $50 a barrel even if ethanol output were to quadruple?
The ethanol lobby is understandably reluctant to discuss the significantly lower engergy content of E85 which as they full well know means that E85 is at parity with gasoline on a dollars per BTU basis--at least. The claims of lowered emissions are spurious at best primarily because current vehicles are already at extremely low levels. Those two factors are unlikely to prompt a groundswell of enthusiam for corn squeezins.
Reply
Chris M 6:14PM (6/24/2008)
Of course their proposed mandate is for all cars to be E85 compatable - they see Biodiesel as a threatening rival, CNG undercuts their price and is cleaner, and of course plug-ins are the biggest potential threat to the ethanol ever.
But such a mandate would have no real effect on oil prices, as there just isn't anywhere near enough ethanol to fuel the existing E85 vehicles, let alone all new ones.
Reply
jpm100 7:37AM (6/25/2008)
Ethanol gave me acne and got my daughter pregnant. Its true.
Reply
boogieman 4:58PM (6/25/2008)
It must be political. Why are Obama and Harkin pushing corn so strongly? Sugar, (ask the Brazilians) produces 8 times the energy of corn in biofuels. The U.S. now subsidizes sugar producers bigtime. They pay the producer then sell it for less on the open market. Florida grows so much sugarcane they must destroy some of it.
Reply