AutoblogGreen Q&A: Tesla Motors Chairman Elon Musk - Epilogue
During the course of our discussion (presented in three parts: Part 1, Part 2 and Part 3).Tesla Motors Chairman Elon Musk described how he came to be a part of Tesla Motors and how he, as "Product Architect," influenced the development of the Roadster as and what will become the WhiteStar sedan. Based on his description of the events, that sounds like a perfectly reasonable title. Even as told by Martin Eberhard, co-architect doesn't seem inaccurate, although Eberhard might have preferred it to be otherwise. One thing that isn't in doubt is that Musk is not a founder.Some in the mainstream media over-simplify things by referring to Musk as the creator of the Roadster, and if anything Musk's sin here may be more an error of omission. By not speaking up to clarify his role in the process previously, he has at least appeared to passively take credit for more than he should. If nothing else, as with so many successful entrepreneurs, his self-assurance can certainly come across as arrogance. I don't know the man personally so I can't really comment as to what he is like on a personal level. Aside from the financial aspects his role is probably most analogous to that of Bob Lutz at GM where he makes high level decisions about design direction which are then brought to fruition by the engineers, designers and technicians. Read on after the jump for the rest of my conclusions.
Based on the available information from those involved it doesn't appear that there is a huge discrepancy about the facts of the story of Tesla. The conflict seems to be more about the interpretation and who's point of view you look at it from. The contentious relationship between Eberhard and Musk very likely exacerbated the problems that the development team had. They certainly didn't help. Mistakes were undoubtedly made on all sides. Fortunately, what will hopefully be the biggest ones appear to have been recognized and addressed before a significant number of these cars are on the road.
Tesla Motors certainly wouldn't be where it is today without both of these men and I think each grudgingly acknowledges that. Musk likely would not have pursued such a project at all had Eberhard, Tarpenning and Wright not already started it. The founders could not have moved forward without Musk's money. The passion of all involved made the Roadster a reality.
Musk obviously has a very strong personality and tends to get what he wants. One thing that became clear in the process of putting this story together is that things are by no means black and white. There are always shades of gray and as I've said before when human emotions get involved, things can turn ugly.
Having met several members of the Tesla team when I visited there in January to drive the Roadster, it's clear to me that they have tremendous skills and expertise and they are recruiting more people wtih those qualities. Hopefully, the management team now in place at Tesla has the strength of character to take the knowledge of the engineers and apply the necessary review process to design decisions going forward. That is an absolute must in order to get cars built right, on time and on budget. Certainly the work of the TEAM at Tesla Motors has lit a fire under many other manufacturers to accelerate their own electric car projects.
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Serge 11:01AM (6/26/2008)
Great series of articles, Sam! This effort to document recent events at TMC was an import step to make for all parties involved. Please treat Martin with respect he deserves, make every effort to get his car delivered as soon as possible and focus changing the future.
Reply
Ryan 11:53AM (6/26/2008)
Thanks for the series, Sam. I really enjoyed it and I appreciate hearing Elon's side of the story.
I will say, though, that he and Tesla do much better and incite more hope and anticipation when they deal in the present and future. I'd suggest they quit trying to remedy/(re)write the past as it really diminishes their credibility
I can only say that despite my continued support for Tesla I'm very, very sorry to not see Eberhard with the company. He was long the face of the company and his openness was refreshing and his passion for the project was contagious.
Cheers.
Reply
Sean 1:48PM (6/26/2008)
I echo Ryan's comment. Couldn't Tesla at least hire Martin as a PR spokesperson/director? The openness and technical accuracy that would bring would be very refreshing and yet another thing that would set the company apart.
Let's at least get some more blog posts from Elon! I know he's a busy guy, but keeping the public jazzed up is essential, especially when everyone's clamoring for more information!
Reply
OhmExcited 2:31PM (6/26/2008)
It would be weird for Tesla to hire Martin back after they've banned him from the Owners' forum. Unfortunately, I don't see it happening.
Reply
Doug 3:03PM (6/26/2008)
Wow, four days of Musk. And now there's more. PBS News Hour did a report on EV's yesterday which you can watch or read here:
http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/transportation/jan-june08/electriccars_06-25.html
Extended interviews with Musk and Rick Wagoner can be found here:
http://www.pbs.org/newshour/indepth_coverage/science/alt_fuels/index.html
Transcript of the extended Musk interview (has more than the video) is here:
http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/science/jan-june08/musk_06-25.html
Reading between the lines, Elon hints at the rational behind the Fisker suit, and a deal to sell power train components to a major (Daimler).
Reply
Doug 3:43PM (6/26/2008)
*rational -> rationale
(an edit feature would be nice)
Reply
TEG 10:56PM (6/26/2008)
Sam wrote:
## "One thing that isn't in doubt is that Musk is not a founder."
He doesn't seem to act that way.
I come across articles all the time saying otherwise. Here are a couple examples:
http://www.pbs.org/thinktank/transcript1292.html
..."MUSK: Sure -- and so I’m chairman and principal FOUNDER OF TESLA, which -- Tesla motors, which is making a revolutionary electric sports car."...
http://www.tcsdaily.com/article.aspx?id=061808B
..."MUSK: Yes. I'm chairman and principal founder of Tesla Motors"...
Reply
vfx 9:54AM (6/27/2008)
Again Sam, great reporting.
Sadly though, Elon's continued stating that he is Founder or his "acts of omission" will continue.
This misinformation, however it is propagated, will be put out there as fact each time the Roadster hits another milestone and when the Whitestar is incrementally revealed. Even more as a hundred thousand of Bluestars are on the road. All that press will beget thousands of articles in the press and they will repeated in EV history books and on the internets into the millions. It will become fact simply by repetition. Even some future journalist digging for the truth will be swayed by time and the saturation of misinformation. Articles like this, if found, will describe the subtle shading of emotional interpetation but will ring as bias, untrue, or unimportant under the overwhelming weight of all the words that have come after it.
Reply
vfx 9:55AM (6/27/2008)
Again Sam, great reporting.
Sadly though, Elon's continued stating that he is Founder or his "acts of omission" will continue.
This misinformation, however it is propagated, will be put out there as fact each time the Roadster hits another milestone and when the Whitestar is incrementally revealed. Even more as a hundred thousand of Bluestars are on the road. All that press will beget thousands of articles in the press and they will repeated in EV history books and on the internets into the millions. It will become fact simply by repetition. Even some future journalist digging for the truth will be swayed by time and the saturation of misinformation. Articles like this, if found, will describe the subtle shading of emotional interpetation but will ring as bias, untrue, or unimportant under the overwhelming weight of all the words that have come after it.
Reply
TEG 5:55PM (6/28/2008)
I hope Chris Paine features Martin & Marc in his "Who Saved the Electric Car" movie.
http://www.whokilledtheelectriccar.com/images/whosavedbanner.jpg
http://www.buckswoodside.com/tales/images/tesla/tesla.jpg
Reply